Reposted with permission from Clouds who recently had this review and nine other protest reviews deleted:
Your review of Non Censure was recently flagged by Goodreads members as potentially off-topic. As the review is not about the book, it has been removed from the site. You can find the text of the review attached for your personal records.
Additionally, your reviews of the following books were recently brought to our attention:
Quotations from Chairman Mao Tsetung
All Flesh is Grass
The 5th Wave
An Uncommon Whore
Logic: A Very Short Introduction
Please note that any reviews you post must contain your own original content (see our review guidelines). Any reviews that are copy-pasted duplicates of other reviews will be removed. Given this, the reviews in question have been deleted. We have attached copies for your personal records.
Please note that if you continue to violate our guidelines, your account may come under review for removal.
The Goodreads Team
Additionally, your review of The Hydra was also removed.
The Goodreads Team
When Goodreads announced their policy change I was annoyed – somewhat because I felt this represented a step towards censorship – but mostly because it was handled in such an unprofessional, cack-handed way.
But we’ve moved on a step since then. We’ve moved past the original issue with reviewers attacking authors in their book reviews. Goodreads is now specifically, systematically removing those reviews written in protest of the initial policy change. They are deleting the voice of the opposition.
I have never written a review attacking an author – it’s just not my thing, and I wasn’t in the firing line – but I was annoyed enough to join the protest movement. And now they’ve started deleting protest reviews, which puts me and a lot of good, thoughtful reviewers, right in the middle of the censor-sniper’s sights. That makes it a lot more personal. That makes me a lot more angry.
I’m now amping up my involvement in the protest movement – this morning I posted 7 Hydra reviews and will be looking at what else I can do when I get home after work (this is my lunch break). They’ve re-drawn the battle lines, so I’m painting a target on my chest.
I’m a sci-fi reviewer – I’ve never caused any problems with anyone on this site – it’s YOUR actions which have instigated this situation Goodreads – and I’m not leaving until you back down or ban me.
1.) Posting this protest review resulted in it being deleted.
2.) Reposting will apparently get my account ‘put under review for removal’.
3.) I’d like to state for anyone ‘reviewing’ this that I fully intend to keep reposting every review I hear about that’s been deleted – because this censorship policy is WRONG.
4) If the only response to that, you’re capable of considering, is removing my account entirely, rather than engaging with your outraged users in meaningful discussion, than just hit the big delete button right now…