The Last Policeman by Ben H. Winters

The Last Policeman

January 2015
Recommended for fans of science fiction and mystery
 ★    ★    ★    ★    

Imagine Spin (my review) crossed with The Manual of Detection (my review) and a suicide investigation. As interpreted by Kant.  What do I mean? Consider:

An asteroid is heading toward Earth. Fast and large, the power of its collision with Earth will cause an explosion “equaling the blast force of a thousand Hiroshimas,”  and the shock waves will cause tsunamis and earthquakes worldwide. Even worse, the resulting environmental destruction will cast a cloud cover over the world, obscuring the sun for years. After prolonged speculation, scientists discover the exact doomsday will be in six months, eleven days. Suddenly, humanity has an expiration date–if not from the disasters, then from starvation.  “Answer this, in your blue books, Professor Palace: what effect does it have on motive, all this information, all this unbearable imminence?”  What will your partner do? Children? Neighbors? The clerks at your grocery store? The plumbers? Doctors?

‘What about you, Dr. Fenton?’
‘Excuse me?’ She stops at the door, looks back.
‘Why haven’t you left, gone off to do whatever it is you’ve always wanted to do?’
Fenton tilts her head, looks at me like she’s not exactly sure she understands the question. ‘This is what I’ve always wanted to do.’

A number of people quit their current lives to chase their dreams, so many in fact, that its become known as ‘going Bucket List.’ Another portion of the population commits suicide. Henry Palace has been working for the Concord Police Department as a patrolman for sixteen months when he is unexpectedly promoted to Detective. Like Fenton, he is doing what he always wanted to do; although unlike Fenton, he’s woefully unprepared. When an apparent suicide is found at the local ‘pirate’ McDonalds (the franchise has disbanded), the rest of the department is ready to dismiss it as another doomsday suicide. Palace notices something odd about the scene, and doggedly persists in investigating as a homicide, even as the rest of the department dismisses his suspicions.

Characterization is excellent.  Palace is interesting character but hardly exciting; methodical, stalwart, imperturbable–and young. He prefers to play a quiet, background role: “So I haven’t mentioned [my history] to a new person in years–don’t mention it as a rule–I am not a fan of people having opinions about the whole thing–not a fan, generally, of people having opinions about me at all.” What is fascinating about the characterization is how Palace accounts for the end-of-world mentality in investigating motive and action. Winters has hit upon the myriad of responses humanity will offer at both personal and international levels.  The plot is methodical, building on the investigation and the characters’ reactions.  It’s not a fast-moving mystery with large-scale, implausible drama; this is small-scale, human reaction of relatively normal people under extreme circumstances.

Technically part of a trilogy, the mystery thankfully has a resolution, although questions remain in the larger arcs of the meteor and Palace’s future. The writing captures Palace’s thought process in rather straightforward, but appropriate, language. It is a nice compliment to the complicated philosophy surrounding each person’s actions. But the writing is not all doom-and-gloom and ethical conundrums. Palace has the dry humor of many police officers confronting humanity’s bizarre behavior:

He doesn’t remember. I stare at him, standing there, still smirking. It’s such a fine line with some people, whether they’re playing dumb or being dumb.

At the end, I wondered “was it worth it?” I’m not sure Palace answered–nor asked–that question, although I certainly did. And I wonder what I would do with only six months. This is the kind of book that asks questions without presenting clear-cut answers. I found I was vaguely unsettled once I realized where Winters was going–or not going–but I respect an author that encourages such complicated thinking. I’m curious to where the story goes next, so I’ll be looking for the next book.




About thebookgator

avid reader and Goodreads reviewer looking for a home.
This entry was posted in Book reviews, Mystery, Science fiction and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

7 Responses to The Last Policeman by Ben H. Winters

  1. Pingback: Lucifer’s Hammer by Larry Niven and Jerry Pournelle | book reviews forevermore

  2. bookmole says:

    Due to your reviews, have now finished these in one big, reading gulp. So very, very enjoyable and so very, very unexpected! Loved the details, loved the small personal things. Was very surprised by the ending, yet it was both satisfactory and unsatisfactory. Go Nico! Go Henry!

    I would give these books 5 out of 5 for execution and writing, 4 out of 5 for the characters, and 6 out of 5 for the idea in the first place.

    Thanks for getting these moved up my list, I thoroughly enjoyed them.

    • thebookgator says:

      Thank you, bookmole. I thought they worked so well together–I’m very glad I did not have to wait months between installments. I completely agree with your rating–on their own, there are parts to the character or plotting that I perhaps find less than satisfactory, but together–well, together they are profound as an arc of dissolution.

  3. Stephen Fisher says:

    Very unique premise. Fun noir feel. Found the pace of the book intriguing. Very measured and exact, like the personality of its lead character Detective Henry Palace. Allows the weight of the approaching asteroid catastrophe time to sink in, until the reader can feel the pall it casts over the characters thoughts and actions. Liked the story and writing style a lot but a few big misses for me. First, a very week ending after such a great buildup. Second, the thread about Henry’s sister Nico was completely unnecessary and a distraction. Finally, I felt robbed by the quick death of Naomi Eddes. A fascinating character whose back story and connection to Henry Palace could have been expanded on enhancing the novel. Three stars for me.

    • thebookgator says:

      Did you continue, Stephen? I agree, I had thought the Nico arc was a distraction in this book, but it carries through the next two and begins to make more sense as we learn more about Henry.

  4. Pingback: The End Has Come | book reviews forevermore

  5. Pingback: The Seep by Chana Porter | book reviews forevermore

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.